Current:Home > reviewsNY governor’s subway mask ban proposal sparks debate over right to anonymous protest -ChatGPT
NY governor’s subway mask ban proposal sparks debate over right to anonymous protest
View
Date:2025-04-18 20:45:37
NEW YORK (AP) — A new proposal by Gov. Kathy Hochul to ban masks on the New York subway is drawing backlash from civil liberties groups and disability advocates, reviving a long-standing debate about the right to anonymous protest that has only grown more complex since the pandemic.
Hochul, a Democrat, backed the idea this week following a spate of confrontations involving masked pro-Palestinian activists that the governor and others have characterized as antisemitic. She said the legislation — which has not yet been crafted — would include “common-sense exemptions” for those who cover their faces for medical or religious reasons.
If the ban does go into effect, New York would join a growing number of states that have embraced laws against public masking to clamp down on activists who conceal their faces at protests.
But the new restrictions raise constitutional questions, according to Jay Stanley, a policy director at the American Civil Liberties Union, since they appear aimed at stopping a specific group from an activity that is widely practiced by members of the public.
“Because mask wearing is such a broad activity, done by so many people for so many reasons, it creates a real danger of selective prosecution against disfavored groups,” he said, adding that “COVID completely scrambled the contours of the debate over arcane mask laws.”
New York previously banned public mask-wearing by groups of three people or more under a law dating back to the 19th century, when upstate tenant farmers dressed as Native Americans and rose up violently against landlords. The law was lifted when COVID-19 struck.
Until two years ago, riders were required to wear masks on public transit.
The effort to reinstate the ban has also rankled the many people who still mask on the subway to protect themselves from the virus, spurring a campaign among disability advocates to pressure Hochul’s office against the idea.
Jason Roth, a Brooklyn resident who suffers from an autoimmune disease, said the measure would only “further stigmatize people who continue to mask,” even if it did include exemptions.
“We don’t feel welcome on public transit already,” he said. “Why should I now have to prove to anyone else that I wear a mask because of a medical condition?”
As protests have grown against Israel’s war in Gaza, a younger generation of activists are increasingly obscuring their faces for reasons unrelated to the virus, citing the threat of harassment and retaliation from universities, employers and other sources, as well as the growing use of facial recognition by police.
But officials argue the tactic emboldens bad actors. Earlier this week, a group of protesters — some wearing traditional Palestinian scarves, known as keffiyehs, over their faces — were seen on video asking whether any passengers aboard a crowded subway were Zionists, telling them: “This is your chance to get out.”
In an interview Thursday on CNN, Hochul said the “unacceptable” incident had pushed her to look at restoring the ban on masks.
“You’re sitting on a subway and someone puts on a mask like this and comes in, you don’t know if they’re going to be committing a crime, they’re going to have a gun, or whether they’re just going to be threatening or intimidating you because you are Jewish, which is exactly what happened the other day,” she said.
Still, it’s unclear whether specific passengers on the car were targeted for their religious or political identities.
Long before the pandemic, the statute against mask-wearing had drawn allegations of selective enforcement, sparking a series of legal challenges that argued the law violated the right to anonymous speech.
One of the highest-profile challenges came in 1999, when the Ku Klux Klan sued the city in order to stage a Manhattan rally in their traditional hoods and robes. After a federal judge sided with the Klan, an appeals court reversed the ruling, noting the state’s right to “regulate conduct that it legitimately considers potentially dangerous.”
More recently, supporters of the Russian feminist band Pussy Riot sought to overturn the law after they were arrested for protesting in New York while wearing balaclavas. The city ultimately dropped charges against the protesters, nullifying the lawsuit.
Norman Siegel, a civil rights attorney who represented both the Klan and the Pussy Riot supporters, said Hochul’s attempts to ban masks on public transit could open up another avenue to challenge the law.
“I understand what they’re trying to do, but we have a long history of peaceful protest and anonymous speech,” Siegel said. “There are major First Amendment implications at stake here.”
veryGood! (66957)
Related
- New Mexico governor seeks funding to recycle fracking water, expand preschool, treat mental health
- Mississippi’s Republican-led House will consider Medicaid expansion for the first time
- Texas wildfire becomes second-largest in state history, burning 500,000 acres
- SF apology to Black community: 'Important step' or 'cotton candy rhetoric'?
- Tom Holland's New Venture Revealed
- Sen. Tammy Duckworth to bring up vote on bill to protect access to IVF nationwide
- Cam Newton started the fight at 7v7 youth tournament, opposing coaches say
- Samsung unveils new wearable device, the Galaxy Ring: 'See how productive you can be'
- The Louvre will be renovated and the 'Mona Lisa' will have her own room
- Avalanche kills 4 skiers in Kyrgyzstan visiting from Czech Republic and Slovakia
Ranking
- Meta donates $1 million to Trump’s inauguration fund
- Sony to lay off 900 PlayStation employees, 8% of its global workforce
- FDA to develop new healthy logo this year – here's what consumers could see, and which foods could qualify
- Biden administration offering $85M in grants to help boost jobs in violence-plagued communities
- Hackers hit Rhode Island benefits system in major cyberattack. Personal data could be released soon
- Florida's response to measles outbreak troubles public health experts
- 'Sopranos' star Drea de Matteo says OnlyFans 'saved' her after vaccine stance lost her roles
- Climate Takes a Back Seat in High-Profile California Primary Campaigns. One Candidate Aims to Change That
Recommendation
Warm inflation data keep S&P 500, Dow, Nasdaq under wraps before Fed meeting next week
Kelly Osbourne Reveals She’s Changing Son Sidney’s Last Name After “Biggest Fight” With Sid Wilson
Raquel Leviss Reacts to Tom Sandoval Comparing Cheating Scandal to George Floyd, O.J. Simpson
Avalanche kills 4 skiers in Kyrgyzstan visiting from Czech Republic and Slovakia
Grammy nominee Teddy Swims on love, growth and embracing change
Kansas City Chiefs DB Coach Says Taylor Swift Helped Travis Kelce Become a Different Man
EAGLEEYE COIN: Senator proposes raising starting point for third-party payment networks
Helicopter’s thermal imaging camera helps deputies find child in Florida swamp